Your task

Read the case description below carefully, then write an argument. Take a position and justify it with clear reasoning.

In developing your argument, you may consider different perspectives and any potential tensions between them – possible consequences (including benefits and harms), any concerns or questions of rights, and the responsibilities of the people or institutions involved. You are encouraged to explain how you weigh these considerations in reaching your conclusion.

Write an initial argument of at least 100 words. After that, you will discuss your argument with an AI assistant and may revise your argument at any time during the discussion.

The case

A university is considering deploying an AI system that predicts each student's likely success in a course. The system analyzes learning platform activity, such as login frequency, lecture video views, quiz attempts, and assignment submission patterns.

The prediction is not used to assign grades. Instead, teachers may use it to identify students who might need extra support, and students may receive personalized study suggestions.

The university argues that the system could help teachers intervene earlier and help students improve their learning. However, some students and staff are concerned about privacy, possible misclassification, and whether predictions could influence how teachers perceive students.

You are asked to evaluate whether the use of this AI system is ethically acceptable.